Math Attitude Surveys: Making Student Beliefs Visible - Math Coach's Corner

Math Attitude Surveys: Making Student Beliefs Visible

Written by Donna Boucher

Donna has been a teacher, math instructional coach, interventionist, and curriculum coordinator. A frequent speaker at state and national conferences, she shares her love for math with a worldwide audience through her website, Math Coach’s Corner. Donna is also the co-author of Guided Math Workshop.

Why use a math attitude survey?

When your students enter your classroom this fall, it’s likely that a very large elephant will follow each of them into the room. That’s a lot of elephants in one room! The source of all this overcrowding? Negative beliefs and attitudes about math.

Our students come to us disliking or distrusting math for a variety of reasons. Unfortunately, many of our students hear their parents speak negatively about math at home. Students may have a history of poor performance in math. Their experiences with math instruction may have been less than engaging. They may not understand the need for math or it doesn’t make sense to them. Whatever their reasons, it’s difficult for learning to occur in the presence of such overwhelming negative vibes. Just like we pre-assess our students to determine their understanding of concepts, such as place value or multiplication, so we know the best entry point for new instruction, it’s equally important that we uncover the attitudes our students have about learning math.

Research in the past decade or so have underscored the connection between mindset and learning. We now know that people display either a fixed or growth mindset. Those with a fixed mindset believe that ability is fixed and their efforts are not likely to impact their success.  You are either good at math or not, and nothing is going to change that. A growth mindset, on the other hand, focuses more on effort and the belief that ability is not fixed. Struggle is good, because it means I’m learning. I may not be good at math yet, but if I keep working hard I can be. Research studies have indicated that a student’s mindset is actually more important to success than innate ability.

In addition to the research on mindset, recent brain research tells us that when we struggle and make mistakes, our brains actually grow. How exciting is that for students to hear? It’s time to teach our students that making mistakes is not only okay, but it’s actually fuel for the brain. That faster is not better, and that what’s important is the process, not the answer.

Using the math attitude survey

There is, of course, a right way and a wrong way to administer an attitude survey.

First, find a survey that measures the attitudes and beliefs that are important to you. If you Google “math surveys for elementary students” you will find links to a wide variety of surveys. I wanted a survey that was easy to administer, would be useful for all grade levels (I remediate K-5), and one that would allow me to collect quantifiable data for beginning- and end-of-year comparisons. After looking at a number of different instruments, I decided that none really fit my purposes, so I created my own.  I developed a “scoring guide” so I will be able to collect and compare beginning- and end-of-year data. I can use the same survey for even my youngest students by administering it using an interview process. This will give me consistent data across all grade levels. I think it will be interesting to see how beginning attitudes about math differ from Kindergarten through 5th grade.

When you administer the survey, you have to make your students feel at ease and clearly communicate the purpose. Assure students that this is not a test, that there are no right or wrong answers, and that it’s not for a grade. Let them know that the purpose of the survey is to help you create an environment that will make them feel comfortable and successful with math instruction in your classroom.

Finally, you have to think carefully about changes you must make to your classroom environment and instruction to impact student beliefs and turn the ship around. Not an easy task. My personal professional development goal this year is helping my students develop a growth mindset, so I am studying growth mindset and brain research and working to incorporate lessons on both into my instruction. It also requires how we ourselves think and talk about math. My plan is to administer the survey at the end of the year so I can measure the success of the changes to my instruction and classroom. Hopefully, I’ll see improvement not only in their attitudes, but also their performance.

If you’d like to give my survey a try, click here to grab your copy. There is both a print and a digital version. If you use it, I hope you’ll come back to this post and comment on your results!

Math Attitude Survey 1

13 Comments

  1. Maree Wood

    Is the maths survey suitable for grade 8 or only the younger groups grade 5 and under

    Reply
    • Donna Boucher

      I think you could use it for any grade.

      Reply
  2. Lianne Reid

    This is a great Idea for getting a sense about what current attitudes students are bringing with them to the classroom towards math. I am curious to hear if you have used the test yet and if it has helped guide your approach with certain students who may be suffering from math anxiety or concerns. Is there a second step/intervention you would recommend for the students who seem to be struggling?

    Reply
    • Donna Boucher

      Great question, Lianne! Yes, it has definitely shaped my instruction. Knowing which students feel more and less confident with math helps we know which students need more and less support. I hope to change the attitudes and beliefs of all of my students by creating a culture where they feel comfortable talking about the math they are doing and successful. I’m anxious to see how their attitudes will change by year end. 🙂

      Reply
  3. Diana Pawson

    thank you for this idea – I recently blogged about the importance of children’s attitudes towards math and how we, as teachers, are crucial to changing that mindset. This tool is perfect because it allows the children to voice their concerns over their math experiences and feel heard. With this tool, it also gives the teachers the ability to see who is comfortable in their math class and who they need to focus on in order to help them achieve the success they need to become a great math student.

    Reply
  4. Shannon

    I just gave the survey today – first day! I’m curious what your thoughts were on the “scores” that students get. Is it the more “points,” the more growth mindset they have or the more confident they feel in their math abilities? Maybe it’s some combination of both? Thanks for any insights you can share!

    Reply
    • Donna Boucher

      It’s really more just their attitude about math, but some of the questions definitely lean toward mindset. It also indicates if they view math as important in their everyday lives. So I guess it’s a good overall picture of their beliefs about math!

      Reply
  5. Sam

    Hi! I tried to open the link to see your full math survey, however, the link seems to take me to a blank page. This is something I’ve tried with my tier 2 and tier 3 students and would love to see how you formatted your survey! Thank you!

    Reply
    • Paula Guarino

      Me too. I tried both links and just get a white page.

      Reply
      • Donna Boucher

        I just tried the links and both are working for me. Here is a direct link to the survey product in my TpT store.

        Reply
    • Donna Boucher

      I’m not sure what link you are clicking on. There are two links in the post that will take you directly to the survey in my TPT store.

      Reply
  6. Audrey Hight

    You did not share what results you got after using your survey at the beginning and the end of the year. I am wondering if students showed significant gains in comfort and confidence about math? This is a goal I have every year.

    Reply
    • Donna Boucher

      I haven’t actually used it yet, Audrey. I just developed the instrument so I can collect data this year as I introduce students to the idea of growth mindset. I hope to see not only an improvement in their confidence about math, but also growth in their mathematical performance.

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This